Amazon
Confession: I’ve been using makeup wipes to remove my makeup for years. They’re convenient (I’ll admit I’m a little lazy when it comes to my beauty routine), cheap and popular — but this convenience can come at a cost. And after talking to dermatologists, I’m convinced I need to make a switch.
“The best makeup removers are ones that are great at breaking down heavy and/or waterproof makeup while being gentle on the skin,” Dr. Shoshana Marmon, a board-certified dermatologist and assistant professor of dermatology at New York Medical College, told HuffPost. This criteria, unfortunately, does not align with most makeup wipes, according to both Marmon and Dr. Asmi Berry, a board-certified dermatologist in Los Angeles.
Advertisement
“Makeup wipes are one of the worst options because many contain ingredients such as alcohol, fragrance, and preservatives that can irritate the skin and disrupt the skin barrier,” Berry said. “They also don’t thoroughly remove makeup and often leave behind residue, which can contribute to breakouts or dryness.”
I’ve definitely noticed my skin feeling dry and overworked after rubbing away at it with a wipe. But if makeup wipes are out, what’s in?
“The type of makeup remover that works best for you depends on your skin type and the makeup you wear,” Berry said. Both she and Marmon recommended oil-based removers for dry and sensitive skin because they can keep the skin hydrated with its natural oils intact while they cleanse. On the other hand, micellar water or gel-based water cleansers are good choices for oily and acne-prone skin that get the job done without the residue and harsh rubbing of makeup wipes.
Advertisement
“While these water-based removers are gentle, they may not be strong enough to remove products that are long-wear or waterproof,” Berry added. “If you wear full-coverage foundation, waterproof mascara, or heavy sunscreen, you may need an oil-based cleanser or a double-cleansing routine to ensure everything is fully removed.” She recommends a gel- or oil-based cleanser first, and micellar water second for people who wear heavier makeup.
It’s also important to pay attention to ingredient labels on makeup removers.
“Glycerin, ceramides, hyaluronic acid, and plant-based oils help hydrate and protect the skin,” Marmon told HuffPost, while “fragrance, alcohol, sulfates, and certain preservatives like parabens can cause dryness and irritation” and should be avoided. Berry agrees, adding that fragrances and alcohols can even “disrupt the natural protective barrier, leading to increased skin sensitivity over time.”
If you’re overwhelmed about the amount of options for makeup removers out there, Marmon and Berry have helped me round up some picks that they recommend to their patients. These work for different skin types and many are just as convenient as makeup wipes without the harsh ingredients.
Advertisement
HuffPost and its publishing partners may receive a share from purchases made via links on this page. Every item is independently selected by the HuffPost Shopping team. Prices and availability are subject to change. The experts consulted for this story do not necessarily endorse the products ahead unless otherwise noted.
1
Amazon
Bioderma Sensibio H2O micellar water
"For my patients, I often recommend fragrance-free and gentle removers that effectively cleanse without disrupting the skin barrier," Berry says. "Bioderma Sensibio H2O micellar water is a good choice for sensitive skin because it removes makeup effortlessly without irritation." Marmon similarly recommends this micellar water, as it's gentle and non-stripping.
The first micellar water ever created, according to the brand, this product has a no-rinse formula so you can just apply it with a cotton pad and then go about your day. It works on face and eyes, is fragrance-free and the bottle comes in several different sizes, including a 3.4-ounce bottle that's great for travel.
2
Amazon
E.l.f. Holy Hydration! makeup melting cleansing balm
"The E.l.f. Cosmetics cleansing balm is great for dry skin as it melts away makeup while nourishing the skin, and contains hyaluronic acid, ceramides, and peptides," Berry said.
The balm is oil-based and transforms from a solid to an oil when you apply it to the skin, making it a good choice for double cleansing as well — just cleanse with micellar water or a water-based cleanser afterward. The tub comes in three sizes, and a little product goes a long way. You only need about a dime-sized amount to get off most everyday makeup.
3
Amazon
La Roche-Posay Toleriane micellar cleansing water
You may have heard of La Roche-Posay's Toleriane line, which includes a HuffPost reader-favorite moisturizer. Marmon likes this micellar cleansing water from the same line because it's "oil-free, won’t clog pores and contains glycerin for hydration." The oil-free formula is both cleansing and toning and is so gentle you can use it on your eyes, lips and entire face. Plus, like the other micellar waters, it's no-rinse, so it doesn't take any more time to apply than a makeup wipe would.
Advertisement
4
Amazon
Embryolisse Lait-Crème Concentré
This editors' pick, the Embryolisse Lait-Crème Concentré, is a HuffPost reader favorite for its versatility. It's technically a moisturizer, but can also be used as a primer, cleansing milk and — you guessed it — makeup remover. Its formula contains hydrating natural ingredients like shea butter and aloe vera to nourish the skin. The multi-purpose product has garnered 4.5 stars on Amazon across almost 31,000 reviews, and multiple reviewers say they've been using it for years.
Promising Amazon review: "This is truly my holy grail product. I was introduced to this brand through Birchbox in 2013 and it's saved my skin in more ways than one. I use this to remove my makeup, to moisturize, AND as a foundation primer. I have angry skin and I've never had an issue with breakouts or clogged pores from using it. I had a terrible problem with dry patches on my face and foundation would just stick to them and flake off. Since I've started using this, my dry patches are gone and my normally oily t-zone has normalized. This replaces several products because it truly is a multi-tasker." — Paula Downie
5
Amazon
Or the fragrance-free Embryolisse Lait-Crème Sensitive
As gentle as the Lait-Crème Concentré is on sensitive skin, it does contain a tiny bit of fragrance. So if you'd rather cut that out entirely in accordance with derms' suggestions or due to allergies, Embryolisse also makes a Lait-Crème Sensitive that's essentially the same product but fragrance-free and hypoallergenic. You can still use the cream for all the same purposes as the original, and it contains the same soothing and nourishing ingredients like aloe vera, shea butter and beeswax.
6
Amazon
The cloth MakeUp Eraser Pro
Another editors' pick, the MakeUp Eraser Pro is a great way to save some money: It's a cloth you can reuse and machine-wash again and again, meaning you won't have to restock as much as you would with something like a liquid cleanser in a bottle. Plus, the MakeUp Eraser cleans with just warm water. The soft surface and lack of harsh ingredients like alcohols make this a safer option for your skin than a makeup wipe.
The cloth has two sides, one short-pile to loosen and remove makeup and one long-pile to exfoliate the skin afterward. You can get the Eraser in a range of different colors and patterns to add some fun personality to your beauty routine.
Promising Amazon review: "This is my 3rd makeup eraser, I like to have multiples when they need washed. I’m not sure the magic but they remove makeup so well. Haven’t used a makeup wipe in years thanks to this. I really appreciate the new design having a loop so I can easily hang it on a towel hook to dry. They hold up well in the wash, as I have washed mine several times and they still work great." — Amazon Customer
Advertisement
7
Amazon
The Ordinary squalane cleanser for dry skin
Squalane, a lipid that is naturally found in your skin's oils, can be incredibly moisturizing for dry skin and is noncomedogenic. That's why we like The Ordinary's Squalane Cleanser, which moisturizes as it removes makeup and is alcohol-, fragrance- and paraben-free. The cleanser melts into an oil and protects the skin's natural barrier as it lifts makeup away. Some reviewers say they enjoy using this as a first cleanse in a double cleansing routine.
Promising Amazon review: "My FAVORITE hands down cleaner EVER!!! Such a little goes so far and removes even my most ultra waterproof eye makeup in less that 5 mins. I love the cream to oil concept and I will never stop buying this" — Tiana
